Skip to content

T.M. Scanlon, Varieties of Reasonableness, in Conversations in Philosophy, Law, and Politics (Ruth Chang & Amia Srinivasan eds., 2024).


Abstract: An examination of Hasan Dindjer’s account in Chapter 13 of the threshold notion of the reasonableness of a decision in terms of the reasons an assessor has for countermanding such a decision in some way or letting it stand. After examining the diverse senses of reasonableness in the work of John Rawls’s and T. M. Scanlon’s contractualism, which Dindjer also discusses, the chapter considers Dindjer’s account of a ‘threshold’ sense of reasonableness and his explanation of why the reasonableness of a decision can be enough to make it one that should not be overruled by a higher-level reviewer, even if it is not entirely correct.