Criminal Justice Institute: Criminal Defense Clinic

Criminal Justice Institute: Criminal Defense Clinic

Professor Dehlia Umunna
Fall-Winter 2020 clinic
5 clinical credits

Students who enroll in this offering may count the credits towards the JD experiential learning requirement.

Enrollment in this clinic will fulfill the HLS JD pro bono requirement.

Open to 3Ls only

Required Clinic Component: Criminal Justice Institute: Criminal Defense Clinic, either fall-winter (4 fall clinical credits + 1 winter clinical credit) or winter-spring (1 winter clinical credit + 5 spring clinical credits). Students must enroll in one of the two clinic offerings (fall-winter or winter-spring) before they are permitted to enroll in this required course.

Additional Co-/Pre-Requisites: Trial Advocacy Workshop (TAW) and Evidence. Students must enroll in both classes separately from the clinic enrollment. Failure to meet the pre/co-requisites by the clinic’s add/drop deadline will result in the student being dropped from this clinic and class.

By Permission: No.

Add/Drop Deadline: August 14, 2020.

LLM Students: Due to Massachusetts Court Practice rules, LLM students are not eligible to enroll.

Multi-Semester: This is a fall-winter course (3 fall classroom credits + 1 winter classroom credit).

Placement Site: HLS.

Mandatory Meetings: All students enrolled in the clinic (fall-winter and winter-spring) must attend mandatory orientation sessions: Monday, Sept. 28 (3-5:30pm), Tuesday, Sept. 29 (3-5:30pm), Wednesday. Sept. 30 (3-5:30pm), Thursday, Oct. 1 (3-4:45pm), Friday, Oct. 2 (3-6:30pm).

Students will examine the nature, functions, dynamics, and ethics of such tasks as interviewing, investigation, examination and cross-examination of witnesses, argument, and other aspects of criminal defense advocacy, both in and out of the courtroom. They will also examine the theory and practice of defense advocacy for minors accused of delinquency, focusing on the constitutional framework of the juvenile justice system. Students will study the Massachusetts juvenile courts, examining the history and philosophy of a separate juvenile system, juvenile court jurisdiction, and the impact of various state agencies on the administration of justice in juvenile court. The class component will attempt to develop a variety of operational and ethical frameworks within which students can understand and evaluate their practice experience.

Students can expect to represent clients on criminal and juvenile delinquency cases in the local courts. In the course of representing clients, students may be required to visit correctional institutions, which necessitate a background check. They may also provide representation to minors in school disciplinary hearings or represent adult clients in appellate or other post-conviction legal proceedings. Students will be responsible for providing complete legal representation to their clients during the course of the term and are expected to work a minimum of twenty hours per week at the Criminal Justice Institute under the supervision of a clinical instructor at the Institute. Students will receive one-to-one supervision, individual critique of their courtroom work, and participate in regular group sessions with their supervisor. Classroom reading and discussion will draw upon and complement the students' experiences as defense counsel.

The teaching method will include exercises and discussions on the Code of Professional Responsibility and the Model Rules of Professional Responsibility. Students will become familiar with the Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, and Fourteenth Amendment rights of both adults and juveniles accused of delinquency, as well as the law of evidence and sentencing. There will be a review of essential lawyering skills in criminal practice.

The clinic and class will start the week after Fall TAW, September 28 – October 2, 2020. During this first week of CJI, all students must attend a number of mandatory orientation sessions: Monday, Sept. 28 (3-5:30pm), Tuesday, Sept. 29 (3-5:30pm), Wednesday. Sept. 30 (3-5:30pm), Thursday, Oct. 1 (3-4:45pm), Friday, Oct. 2 (3-6:30pm). Starting this first week and throughout the Fall, class will meet on Tuesdays and Thursdays from 5:00 PM - 7:00 PM.  During the winter, class will meet on Wednesdays and Thursdays from 1:00 PM - 3:00 PM.  There will be a mandatory mini-orientation session on Thursday, January 7, 2021, for students enrolled in the winter-spring clinic; winter-spring clinic students required to attend all orientation sessions scheduled in September and January.

Arraignments for those enrolled in the fall-winter clinic will be held during the month of October. Those enrolled in the winter-spring clinic will be attending arraignments during the month of January. All students must have at least one morning available for court, Monday through Thursday. Juvenile cases are heard only on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Wednesdays.

Students enrolled in the fall-winter clinic will submit a reflection paper in mid-January. Those enrolled in the winter-spring clinic will be submitting their paper the first week of May.

This course satisfies the professional responsibility requirement.

Subject Areas: Procedure & Practice, Criminal Law & Procedure